DUPE REVIEW: Urban Decay Naked 1 vs Make Up Revolution London Iconic 1 (Swatches included)

There are many urban decay dupes out there on the market, but its hard to know which ones are worth it. £37 can be quite a lot to invest in a make up palette, particularly if you are just starting out and want to practice by copying Urban Decay youtube tutorials but don’t want to fork out for the look. So, as mentioned in my previous youtube haul, I think I’ve finally found the perfect duplicate. 
It’s from Make Up Revolution London, and funnily enough, I bought it about a minute after I bought the Urban Decay palette, without realising! That’s why I own them both. However, below I’m going to show you the swatches on darker skin (as some of the colours are quite light), and let you know which particular colours are better on each palette. Hopefully with that information you’ll be able to decide which one to go for, the luxury palette or the drugstore one!

ABOVE: SWATCHED FROM BOTH PALLETTES LEFT TO RIGHT. URBAN DECAY IS ON THE TOP, AND MAKE UP REVOLUTION LONDON IS ON THE BOTTOM. SEE IMAGES BELOW FOR COLOUR NAMES.


Above you can see the comparison between the two palettes, and they look almost the same! However, there are some slight differences…

VIRGIN VS ONE

I noticed that Virgin brushed on more easily than the one on the Iconic palette. Most of the colours on the Urban Decay palette pick up more easily when you place the brush on them, which is an advantage. However, the Iconic palette one (for this colour) had a slight shimmer.

SIN VS TWO

This one is one of the two that I deem to be the most differing. On my skin, Sin is almost barely there but it has a really lovely shimmer. This one I’d use to highlight the inside of my eyes nearest to my nose. The Iconic two colour turned out a slightly more off pink, however it has better pigmentation than Sin. It has quite a lot of shimmer too.

NAKED VS THREE

These two came out exactly the same. Unfortunately for me, they’re my exact skin colour so they made my skin just look ashy- I don’t think I’ll be using this colour on either palette any time soon! On a lighter skin tone however, they would look gorgeous.

SIDECAR VS FOUR

This colour is a beautiful pale pink, but in this round it was Sidecar that won it! The iconic palette version had poor pigmentation and it took many layers to get it as thick as Sidecar. 

BUCK VS FIVE

Buck is a brown with a slight purple pigmentation to it. It had better pigmentation than Five did. Five was also almost the same colour as my skin tone, so it was pretty much invisible for me! I’d imagine it wouldn’t be consistent on lighter skin.

HALF BAKED VS SIX

These two once again were basically exactly the same! I love gold and brown tones on my skin, so this is for sure another one of my favourite colours. It’s another one I’d use to highlight my eyes, nearest to my nose to make them look bigger.

SMOG VS SEVEN

These two shades were the same in consistency and pigmentation. This one was my favourite because it was almost my skin tone, but really shimmery! It would blend nicely with Half Baked for some golden brown eyeshadow glory.

DARK HORSE VS EIGHT

Dark Horse is darker than eight and has less shimmer. This can be used for a dark brown smoky look, but there isn’t too much of a difference between the two different palettes on this one.

TOASTED VS NINE

The Urban Decay Toasted is less saturated than Nine on the Iconic palette. However, they both make for a great light pink colour.

HUSTLE VS TEN

If you look at the two palettes and compare these two colours, they couldn’t seem more different. However the consistency is the same, and they both come out as really dark ashy browns.

CREEP VS ELEVEN

These last two dark blues are gorgeous! Creep is ashier on the Urban Decay palette than its alternative on the Iconic palette.

GUNMETAL VS TWELVE

What I love about this colour and Creep, is that their shimmer really reminds me of a starry night. That being said, Gunmetal has more pigmentation than Twelve does.
So who won? For me, the urban decay palette. But I own the dupe of Naked 3, and because I don’t actually own the original, I don’t feel like I’m losing out on much because the rosy gold colours of that palette are beautiful. However, they are good substitutes for the moment until I am ready to purchase the originals.
Products in this post:
  • URBAN DECAY NAKED PALLETTE CAN BE PURCHASED FROM SELFRIDGES 
  • MAKE UP REVOLUTION ICONIC PALLETTES CAN BE PURCHASED FROM SUPERDRUG
What do you think? Do you own any of the Naked palettes at all? 

FOLLOW US ON BLOGLOVIN FOLLOW ME ON TWITTER FOLLOW ME ON INSTAGRAM / SUBSCRIBE ON YOUTUBE
*ALL PR SAMPLES IN ANY POST WILL CLEARLY BE MARKED WITH AN ASTERIX.
FOR OUR FULL DISCLAIMER, READ HERE.

Follow:

22 Comments

    • January 24, 2015 / 11:35 pm

      Thank you! I hope to invest in those soon 🙂 x

    • January 24, 2015 / 11:37 pm

      I know! Im happy i found it x

    • January 24, 2015 / 11:38 pm

      They're lovely 🙂 x

    • January 24, 2015 / 11:38 pm

      You're welcome, glad this was of some help x

  1. January 23, 2015 / 6:28 pm

    Wow they look so similar!! I have the iconic 3 palette which is a dupe for the Naked 3 palette. Great post x

    OhjustAlice.blogspot.co.uk

    • January 24, 2015 / 11:38 pm

      I have that one, its so nice! thanks xx

    • January 24, 2015 / 11:38 pm

      They're lovely shades x

    • January 24, 2015 / 11:39 pm

      I love them! x

  2. January 24, 2015 / 9:55 am

    Wow who would have guessed, I saw the revolution palettes in Superdrug but I wasn't sure whether to get them or not. I will definitely be investing.

    bubbasdoll.blogspot.co.uk

    • January 24, 2015 / 11:39 pm

      One more to get and then i'll be all complete 🙂 x

    • January 25, 2015 / 7:38 pm

      You're welcome! x

  3. May 31, 2015 / 2:32 am

    Great review! First time I've seen a palette look exactly the same as the naked 1, even the sequence of colors are the same.

    mykikaystuff.com

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *